System Change

Share this post

Truss's extreme right-wing putsch

annpettifor.substack.com

Discover more from System Change

I write about the international financial system and its impact on society, the economy and the ecosystem.
Over 4,000 subscribers
Continue reading
Sign in

Truss's extreme right-wing putsch

The Budget for the Very Rich

Ann Pettifor
Sep 24, 2022
17
Share this post

Truss's extreme right-wing putsch

annpettifor.substack.com
1
Share

Budgets often reflect nothing more than the dreams and aspirations of a finance minister. Today Britain’s finance minister presented a budget which revealed something more sinister. The overthrow of the Johnson government was indeed a secretly plotted and suddenly executed attempt to dislodge the electoral mandate (for “levelling up”) of a government and replace it with an undemocratic mandate to serve the interests of the very rich, while bearing (or “levelling”) down on the poor.

This IS the right wing Revolt of the Rich.

Twitter avatar for @AnnPettifor
Ann Pettifor @AnnPettifor
Thread: This budget represents a putsch by the undemocratic extreme right wing of the Tory Party...Truss and co have no electoral mandate.
11:08 AM ∙ Sep 23, 2022
2,234Likes566Retweets

Johnson’s elected government’s 2019 manifesto promised: "Millions more invested every week in science, schools, apprenticeships and infrastructure while controlling debt." Today, the Debt Management Office reported effectively that debt was no longer being controlled - but would expand by £72 billion by the end of this year -£45bn of which is attributed to the debt-financed tax-cutting package “that sparked a historic increase in borrowing costs.”

Britain now has an extreme right-wing government with no electoral mandate, and one supported by a minority of Tory MPs in a deeply divided governing party.

An unelected government that has chosen this moment to use the power of the state to capture public wealth and divert it to the top ranks of the private sector - bankers, investors, developers and speculators. At the same time the poor are threatened with the loss of livelihoods if they do not single-handedly increase their own meagre earnings. They are expected to do this as the economy is deliberately plunged into recession by a combination of inflationary rises in globalised energy and food prices; by a corresponding fall in real (inflation-adjusted) wages; and by the ratcheting up of interest rates by the Bank of England.

Speaking of the Bank of England: that institution is now engaged in open conflict with the Liz Truss regime and Kwasi Kwarteng, the new finance minister - a conflict that can only end in economic upheaval.

Twitter avatar for @Gus_ODonnell
Gus O'Donnell @Gus_ODonnell
I joined Treasury in 1979 and have never seen a fiscal stimulus this large. With Bank of England raising interest rates, economy is being driven with brake and accelerator hard down. Not ideal.
8:07 PM ∙ Sep 23, 2022
766Likes231Retweets

Yesterday the Bank published a statement on the decision of the members of its Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) to raise the Bank rate of interest to 2.25% and admitted that consumer price inflation is not worsening, but is already falling - “from 10.1% in July to 9.9% in August. It also asserted dishonestly that “nominal wages have continued to rise.” Nominal wages are not real wages and economists at the Bank of England know that. Real Wages are falling. Bank of England economists know that too.

An economy in which public wealth is deliberately siphoned upwards to the few and away from both the majority, but also from investment in productive, income and tax revenue-generating activity; one in which public borrowing is aimed at tax breaks for the 1% that do not spend their new wealth, while both private and public borrowing is deliberately made more costly - is an economy driven “with both accelerator and hand brake hard down.”

It is one in which globalised markets, and the wider British public will quickly lose confidence. Indeed markets on the day of the Budget began by shorting the Pound - causing sterling to fall close to parity with the dollar. As more than half of all energy and food consumed in Britain is imported - a weakened sterling will fuel inflation, and drive wages down further.

Twitter avatar for @jonsopel
Jon Sopel @jonsopel
If you’re thinking about a nice Christmas trip to the US,maybe think again. It’s going to cost you a fortune. The £ was 1.38 against the $ this time a year ago.
Image
11:37 AM ∙ Sep 23, 2022
2,764Likes753Retweets

Kwasi Kwarteng - now dubbed Kami-Kwasi - is described by some commentators as a “Keynesian”. Indeed the BBC’s Newsnight placed a journalist reporting on Kwarteng in front of King’s College - Cambridge’s wealthiest college, saved by Keynes’s investment strategy after he failed to predict the 1929 Crash.

But to align Kwarteng with Keynes is profoundly wrong. Keynes did not advocate policies that would cause the public debt to rise. He rightly argued that a rise in public debt was the consequence of private market failure and public sector cuts - a fact proved by the Osborne term as finance minister. The more austerity worsened the post-Global Financial Crisis recession, the higher rose the UK’s public debt, as we explained in 2016 in The Economic Consequences of Mr Osborne:

Some six years later, vast damage has been inflicted on public services and the public sector workforce. Five years of consolidation became ten years, with total spending cuts virtually doubling in size. The economy has barely expanded in per capita terms relative to the pre-crisis peak, and public sector debt as a share of GDP is still rising in spite of a vast fire sale of public assets.

In periods of full employment and prosperity, public debt falls, as the 1945 -51 Labour government so comprehensively proved. And as Geoff Tily has argued in Keynes Betrayed

Keynes was primarily concerned with the prevention of crisis through monetary reform; the use of fiscal policy in the event of crisis was a secondary consideration. Likewise, some international context is unavoidable, given monetary policies are inherently global in institutional terms and practical effect.

Twitter avatar for @Hardeep_Matharu
Hardeep Matharu @Hardeep_Matharu
"Giving hand-outs to the wealthiest at a time of major recession seems incredibly reckless. While some will seek to construct an electoral logic to it, the only explanation that makes any sense is it is ideological" Incisive analysis from @AdamBienkov 👇 bylinetimes.com/2022/09/23/liz…
bylinetimes.comLiz Truss’ Economic Shock Doctrine Will Only Help the Richest – Byline TimesThe Chancellor Kwasi Kwarteng today announced a series of massive tax cuts for high earners and corporations, which risk turning an economic crisis into a disaster, writes Adam Bienkov
12:39 PM ∙ Sep 23, 2022
143Likes59Retweets

The government’s Debt Management Office followed the Budget with the announcement that its Net Financing Requirement (NFR) for 2022-23 is rising by £72.4 billion to £234.1  billion following the publication today of the Government’s Growth Plan. The increase will be financed by: 

  • additional gilt sales of £62.4 billion, taking the planned total in 2022-23 to £193.9 billion; and 

  • additional net sales of Treasury bills for debt management purposes of £10.0 billion, taking  the planned increase in 2022-23 to £40.2 billion and the planned stock at end-March 2023  to £77.0 billion.

This comes the day after the Bank of England announced that it was going to commence with ‘Quantitative Tightening” - by selling £80bn of gilts (bonds) over the next 12 months.

For both government and central bank to be dumping billions of gilts into a global “bear market” for bonds, is courageous - to say the least.

Twitter avatar for @lisaabramowicz1
Lisa Abramowicz @lisaabramowicz1
This Great Bond Bear Market is "thus far a doozy," with the worst losses since 1949, 1931 & 1920: BofA's Hartnett. This "threatens credit events & liquidations of the most crowded trades," long dollar, PE, big tech. "True capitulation is when investors sell what they love & own"
Image
8:32 AM ∙ Sep 23, 2022
663Likes182Retweets

(PS the American “doozy” means “something outstanding or unique of its kind.”)

This insurrection by a political elite on behalf of the very rich may be put down quickly - by Tory MPs. It may also be sustained until the next General Election - not due until 2024. But history has a knack of repeating itself:

Twitter avatar for @AnnPettifor
Ann Pettifor @AnnPettifor
So we now have a return to Barber's disastrous "dash for growth" and Lawson's 1988 "giveaway budget". After which, in the third quarter of 1990, the economy crashed. Watch this space.
11:08 AM ∙ Sep 23, 2022
206Likes54Retweets

It took three years for Lawson’s boom to bust. Does that mean Kwarteng’s boom may not bust before a General Election?

To pose a different question: will this putsch lead to a wider public revolt - against this government of the rich, sooner rather than later? And if so, what form will that revolt take? The institutions to watch are the British trades unions. Will the numerous strikes now taking place - and the Truss government’s determination to further shackle trade union organisations - lead to more strikes and greater working class cohesion?

Watch this space - and this working class woman - general secretary of Britain’s biggest and wealthiest union: Sharon Graham.

Twitter avatar for @UniteSharon
Sharon Graham @UniteSharon
One Year: 🔴Total number of disputes: over 450. ⚪️End of August 2022 - total number of ongoing disputes: 122 (including strikes and strike ballots). 🔴Members in dispute August 2021 to August 2022: over 76,000. ⚪️Disputes win rate: 80%. ➡️Total won: £150m.
5:02 PM ∙ Sep 22, 2022
282Likes131Retweets

Leave a comment

17
Share this post

Truss's extreme right-wing putsch

annpettifor.substack.com
1
Share
1 Comment
Share this discussion

Truss's extreme right-wing putsch

annpettifor.substack.com
Kate Maclean
Sep 29, 2022Liked by Ann Pettifor

Excellent piece- so clear- thank you.

Makes me think that ‘right wing’ isn’t a useful term any more. Truss has managed to appall both the neoliberals and the traditionalists at once. A particularly destructive ideological populism with added incompetence.

Expand full comment
Reply
Share
Top
New
Community

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2023 Ann Pettifor
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start WritingGet the app
Substack is the home for great writing